Avery finds Dylan at the bar, and gives him back his dog tags. Nick is floored when he sees them there together. Phyllis overhears Traci tell Jack her concerns about their relationship. Phyllis uses work as an excuse to get out of their dinner plans. At On The Blvd, a suspicious Michael questions Carmine. Later, Michael puts the pieces together and goes home to confront Lauren. Leslie and Neil visit the police station to get updates on the burglary in Neil's apartment. Fen tells Lauren that he loves Summer but knows that she doesn't feel the same way. Lauren tells him to not give up on her. Meanwhile, Summer asks Kyle to take her to the senior prom.